Blog

How to Write Your First Pen Pal Letter: What 1,909 Openings Tell Us

We looked at every opening letter on PenPalConnect to see which ones got an answer. Short openings did as well as medium ones, long ones did worse, and stacking up questions did not help. Here is how to use that.

By Sander · August 24, 2026 · 4 min read

A white envelope on a black background
Photo by Valeria Reverdo on Unsplash

Updated November 2026. Based on 1,909 opening letters between PenPalConnect members. Only word counts, question marks and whether a reply came were counted; no letter was read. Groups smaller than 20 are not reported. Demo profiles and classroom accounts are left out.

Most first-letter advice, including the earlier version of this post, says roughly the same thing: write about 200 words, ask a couple of good questions, show you read their profile. I wanted to know how much of that holds up on this site, so I counted.

What gets an answer

Overall, 76% of opening letters get a reply. Here is how that changes with length:

Opening letter length Answered Letters
Under 50 words 77% 1,580
50–149 words 77% 276
150–299 words 61% 41
300+ words too few to report

And with the number of questions in it:

Questions in the opening Answered Letters
None 77% 1,374
One or two 76% 476
Three or more 61% 59

Two things stand out.

Length beyond a short message didn't help. A 30-word opening and a 120-word opening were answered just as often. The long ones did worse, though there were only 41 of them, so treat that as a hint rather than a law.

Piling on questions didn't help either. One or two questions did no better than none, and three or more did noticeably worse. A string of questions can read like a form to fill in.

A caution about what this shows. These are correlations, not experiments. People who write 250-word openings may differ in other ways too, such as who they write to or how they write. What the numbers do support is that you don't need a long, polished first letter to get a reply. Most successful openings here are short.

So what should a first letter be?

Short, specific, and easy to answer. On this site, that looks like a few sentences:

  1. Who you are, in a line. Name, roughly where you are, one thing you actually do with your time.
  2. Why them. One thing from their profile that caught your eye. It's the line that proves you're not pasting the same message to fifty people.
  3. At most one or two easy questions, or none, if the "why them" line already invites an answer.

For example:

Hi Kenji, I'm Sofia, a primary teacher in Bologna. I saw you're in Sapporo. I've wondered since I saw a documentary about the snow festival whether that much snow ever stops being impressive when you live with it every winter.

That is about 45 words. It says who she is, shows she read his profile, and gives him something easy and fun to answer, without a single question mark.

What to leave out

  • Your whole life story. There will be time for it if the conversation takes off.
  • Anything heavy or intense. A stranger can't hold that yet. Intensity in a first letter is also a classic opening move of romance scams, so it puts people on guard even when it's sincere.
  • Compliments on their looks. This isn't a dating site, and a compliment changes what the letter is.
  • Other contact details. Keep it on the platform for a while; that's where blocking and reporting work. Someone pushing hard to move elsewhere in the first letter is telling you something.

When nobody replies

One in four openings goes unanswered, so it will happen to you. It's rarely about the letter. People join, get busy and drift.

The numbers point to one fix: write more first letters, not longer ones. If three of every four openings get an answer, four short openings will usually get you about three conversations. One long, carefully crafted letter is still a single coin toss.

Also check the other side of it. Your profile is what people read before deciding whether to answer you. A specific profile, with the odd job, the strange hobby, the thing you're stubbornly learning, gives a curious reader a reason to write back. The profile guide covers that.

After they write back

Now the rules change. Once you have a reply, answer everything they asked and match their length roughly. That's where a conversation becomes a correspondence. Seven in ten conversations here reach a third letter, and what happens after that is a slower, steadier story than the usual advice suggests.

Ready to write one? Make a free profile and find someone worth writing to.

Keep reading

All posts →
📸 View once ·